A lot of people working from home in London end up choosing between two jobs: a garden room at the bottom of the garden, or a loft conversion. Both give you a room with a door that shuts. They’re very different builds though, with different rules, costs and problems.
Here’s how they compare on site.
How separate does the office need to be?
A garden room is out of the house. You walk across the garden, shut the door, and the noise from the kitchen stays in the kitchen. For people on calls all day that’s the main reason to build one.
A loft is still inside. Two floors up from the kitchen it’s quiet enough for most people, but you’ll still hear the front door and the kids on the stairs. If you want to be able to pop down for lunch or keep an ear on the house, that’s a plus. If you want to forget the house exists for eight hours, it isn’t.
Garden room: the rules
Most garden rooms go up under permitted development as an outbuilding, so no planning application. The rules are in Class E of the General Permitted Development Order 2015. The height limit is the one that catches people out:
“the height of the building, enclosure or container would exceed— (i) 4 metres in the case of a building with a dual-pitched roof, (ii) 2.5 metres in the case of a building, enclosure or container within 2 metres of the boundary of the curtilage of the dwellinghouse, or (iii) 3 metres in any other case”
GPDO 2015, Schedule 2, Part 1, Class E.1(e)
In a London garden almost everything is within 2 metres of a fence, so in practice most garden rooms are built to 2.5 metres. That’s measured from the highest ground next to the building, so on a sloping garden the base height counts.
The same Class E says the eaves can’t go over 2.5 metres, the building can’t have more than one storey (so no mezzanine), and outbuildings can’t cover more than 50% of the garden. It doesn’t apply at all at a listed house. In a conservation area you can’t put one between the side wall of the house and the boundary.
The law also says what an outbuilding is for: a “purpose incidental to the enjoyment of the dwellinghouse”. The interpretation section spells out that this includes “the keeping of poultry, bees, pet animals, birds or other livestock”. A home office is fine. A bedroom isn’t, because that’s not incidental, that’s living accommodation.
Flats and maisonettes don’t have permitted development rights, so a garden room for a ground-floor flat normally needs planning.
Building regulations are a separate question. The exemption is in Schedule 2 of the Building Regulations 2010, Class 6 “Small detached buildings”:
“A detached single storey building, having a floor area which does not exceed 30m², which contains no sleeping accommodation and is a building— (a) no point of which is less than one metre from the boundary of its curtilage; or (b) which is constructed substantially of non-combustible material.”
Under 15 m² with no sleeping accommodation it’s exempt anyway. Between 15 and 30 m², it has to be a metre off the boundary or built substantially of non-combustible material, and timber-framed garden rooms usually aren’t.
The same Class 6 also exempts a building “designed and intended to shelter people from the effects of nuclear, chemical or conventional weapons”, up to 30 m². The rules for a bunker and a garden office sit in the same paragraph. The electrics still have to be done by a registered electrician and certified.
Garden room: what the build involves
The base is a concrete slab, ground screws or small piles. Near trees, piles or screws do less damage to roots. If you’re digging within 3 metres of a neighbour’s building and going deeper than their foundations, section 6 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 applies, and the notice has to be served “at least one month before beginning to excavate”. That can include a neighbour’s garage or an old brick outbuilding on the boundary. A lot of London trees have preservation orders, and in a conservation area you have to give the council six weeks’ notice before cutting back most trees.
Power goes down the garden in armoured cable, buried in a trench, usually around 600 mm deep. Bring a data cable in the same trench. Wi-Fi from the house often doesn’t reach the end of a London garden reliably.
Insulation matters more than people think. A badly insulated garden room is too cold to use in January and too hot in July, especially with a lot of glass facing south. Most people end up with a small air conditioning unit that heats and cools.
On site, a garden room is quick. Usually two to six weeks, and the house isn’t touched. Access is the problem. On a terrace with no side passage, every bag of concrete and every panel comes through the house.
The trade-off is garden space. In a typical London garden of 10 or 12 metres, a 3 by 4 metre room takes a big bite out of it.
Loft conversion: the rules
A rear dormer on a terraced or semi-detached house often falls under permitted development, Class B of the same 2015 Order. The volume limit is the line that matters:
“the cubic content of the resulting roof space would exceed the cubic content of the original roof space by more than— (i) 40 cubic metres in the case of a terrace house, or (ii) 50 cubic metres in any other case”
GPDO 2015, Schedule 2, Part 1, Class B.1(d)
“Original” means the roof as it was built, or as it stood on 1 July 1948 for older houses. If a previous owner already added a dormer, that volume counts towards the 40 or 50. The dormer has to be set back about 20 cm from the eaves and can’t face the street. In a conservation area, permitted development for roof extensions doesn’t apply, so you’ll need planning. Get a Lawful Development Certificate even if you don’t need permission. Solicitors ask for it when you sell.
Building regulations always apply to a loft conversion. The big ones:
- a new floor structure, as the existing ceiling joists aren’t built to be a floor;
- a protected escape route, usually fire doors to every habitable room off the stairs and mains-wired linked smoke alarms;
- insulation to current standards in the roof and the dormer;
- a proper staircase, with enough headroom over it.
On a terrace or semi the steels usually sit on the party wall, so a party wall notice goes to the neighbours two months before work starts.
Loft conversion: what the build involves
Head height decides whether it’s worth doing. Measure from the top of the ceiling joists to the underside of the ridge. Under about 2.2 metres, a conversion gets difficult and expensive, because either the roof gets raised or the ceiling below gets dropped.
Where the stairs go matters just as much. The new flight usually comes off the existing landing and often takes space from a bedroom or the box room.
The mansard, which is the common option on London terraces where a dormer isn’t enough, is named after François Mansart, a French architect from the 1600s. Under permitted development it almost never qualifies, so it goes through full planning.
A typical dormer conversion is six to ten weeks on site. Most families stay in the house. The roof is opened from outside and the hole into the loft is cut near the end, but it’s still dusty and noisy, and there’s scaffolding on the house for the whole job.
For an office, light is good. Rooflights at the front and a dormer window at the back give more daylight than most rooms downstairs. Low ceilings at the eaves are fine for storage and built-in joinery, but not for a desk.
Cost
Prices vary a lot across London, so treat these as rough. A well-built, insulated garden office of around 12 m², with base, power and data, is usually £20,000 to £40,000. A rear dormer loft conversion in London usually starts somewhere around £50,000 to £60,000 and goes up from there with a bathroom or a mansard.
The loft costs more, but you get a room that counts as part of the house.
Value when you sell
A loft conversion adds floor area and usually a bedroom. Estate agents count it and buyers understand it straight away.
A garden room is generally seen as a nice extra, not as part of the house. It adds appeal but it doesn’t add a bedroom, and legally it can’t be one.
What about a garage conversion or an extension?
If there’s an attached or integral garage, converting it is often cheaper than either. It usually falls under permitted development, but some newer estates have that right removed, so check the original planning conditions. Building regulations apply: the floor gets raised and insulated, and the garage door is replaced with an insulated wall and a window.
A small rear extension costs more per square metre than a garden room, because of foundations, steels and opening up the back of the house. It does join the house though, and usually changes how the ground floor works, not just adds an office. If you need more than an office, an extension or a loft is usually better money.
Which one fits your house
The house usually decides. A long garden and a loft without enough headroom points to a garden room. A small garden but a good loft with 2.2 metres or more of head height points to a loft conversion.
| Option | Usually better when… | Main benefit | Main caution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garden room | The garden is long enough and you want to be out of the house | Quick build, house not touched, quiet | Takes garden space, needs proper insulation and power |
| Loft conversion | The loft has enough head height and room for stairs | Adds a full room that counts when you sell | Building regs, party wall and more disruption |
Before choosing, measure the loft head height and work out how much outdoor space you’d be left with after a garden room. Those two numbers rule out one option more often than cost does. If the house is in a conservation area, check that too, as it changes the rules for both.
Planning a project in London?
Talk it through with Force Builders Ltd — straight answers, no obligation. Over 25 years building across London.
Force Builders Ltd is a London building company (Companies House 07049787) delivering house extensions, loft conversions and full refurbishments across Greater London. See our projects or get in touch.
