Skip to content
Roofer inspecting roof tiles to decide between repair and replacement

Posts

Roof Repair or Replacement? How to Know What Your Roof Really Needs

When a roof starts causing trouble, most homeowners ask the same question: can it be repaired, or is it time to replace the whole thing?

Most roof leaks in London come from the details, not the slates. Flashings round chimneys, valleys, the joint where a rear addition meets the main wall, a blocked gutter behind a parapet. Fix those and a roof can carry on for years. When the covering itself is worn out across the whole slope, repairs stop working.

The job is to work out which of the two you have.

Repair: when the roof is basically sound

A repair is the right call when the fault is in one place and the rest of the covering is in decent shape. A few slates slipped after a storm, a cracked tile, a loose ridge, lead flashing lifted round a chimney, a gutter that’s been overflowing into the wall. Those are repairs.

It has to fix the cause. Mastic over a leak at a chimney will hold for a season, but if the lead has split or the chimney mortar is letting water into the brickwork, it comes back. A blocked outlet on a flat roof will push water under the membrane no matter how many patches go on.

A slate roof often looks worse than it is. Individual slates can be cut out and replaced with a copper or lead tingle holding the new one in place. That’s a normal repair on a Victorian terrace and doesn’t mean the roof is failing.

Do repairs need permission?

Usually not. Like-for-like repair isn’t development at all under planning law. The Act excludes works for the maintenance, improvement or other alteration of a building which:

“(i) affect only the interior of the building, or (ii) do not materially affect the external appearance of the building, and are not works for making good war damage”

Town and Country Planning Act 1990, section 55(2)(a)

Replacing a few slates, relaying a ridge, renewing lead in the same material all fall under that. Changing the look does not. Swapping Welsh slate for concrete tiles can materially affect the appearance, and in a conservation area with an Article 4 direction the council can treat that as needing permission. At a listed house even like-for-like re-roofing may need listed building consent.

The phrase about war damage is still in the 1990 Act. Rebuilding bomb-damaged houses was deliberately kept inside planning control, so it couldn’t be passed off as maintenance.

Replacement: when the covering has had its day

Replacement makes sense when the problem isn’t one place but the whole roof. Signs that point that way:

  • slates slipping all over the slope, not in one spot, which usually means the nails have rusted through;
  • daylight through the roof from inside the loft;
  • underlay that’s torn, perished or missing;
  • sagging between rafters or along the ridge;
  • damp in several rooms, or the same leak coming back after repairs;
  • a roof that’s already been patched several times in the last few years.

Slipping across the whole roof is called nail sickness. Victorian roofers mostly fixed slates with iron nails, and after a century or so those nails corrode. The slates themselves are often fine and can be reused, but the only way to fix the nails is to strip the roof, re-batten and re-hang.

A lot of original London roofs never had underlay. The underside of the slates was “torched” with lime mortar to keep out wind-driven rain. If you look up in the loft and see slates and battens with nothing in between, that roof has done well, but any re-roof will add a breathable membrane.

Most roofs in those streets are Welsh slate. Slate from North Wales quarries such as Penrhyn and Dinorwic came to London by sea and later by rail, and it went onto most of the terraces built in the 1800s. Good Welsh slate can last well over a century. It’s usually the nails, battens and flashings that give out first.

Weight matters when you change material

If a slate roof is being replaced with something heavier, the structure has to take it. Concrete interlocking tiles can be close to double the weight of slate per square metre. Requirement A1 of the Building Regulations covers it:

“The building shall be constructed so that the combined dead, imposed and wind loads are sustained and transmitted by it to the ground— (a) safely; and (b) without causing such deflection or deformation of any part of the building, or such movement of the ground, as will impair the stability of any part of another building.”

Building Regulations 2010, Schedule 1, Part A1(1)

On site this means checking the rafters and purlins before choosing the covering. A roof that was swapped from slate to concrete tiles in the 1960s or 70s and now sags in the middle of each slope is a familiar sight in London. The re-roof is a good time to put it right, either with new timbers or going back to slate.

Replacing the covering also counts as renovating a thermal element, so building control will usually want insulation brought up to standard. The new roof cost guide covers that and the scaffold side.

Rooflights and other changes

A re-roof is when people add rooflights or a solar panel. Rooflights on most houses fall under Class C of the permitted development rules, as long as they stay close to the roof:

“the alteration would protrude more than 0.15 metres beyond the plane of the slope of the original roof when measured from the perpendicular with the external surface of the original roof”

GPDO 2015, Schedule 2, Part 1, Class C.1(b)

So a flush conservation-style rooflight is fine, and a big raised unit can need planning. A rooflight on a side slope has to be obscure-glazed and non-opening below 1.7 metres from the floor. Flats don’t have these rights at all.

What to check before deciding

A roof can’t be judged properly from the pavement. Somebody has to get up on it, or at least into the loft and onto a scaffold tower or cherry picker for the main slopes. The things that decide it:

How old the covering is and what it is. Slate, clay tile, concrete tile and flat roof felt all wear out at different rates.

Whether the problem is local or spread across the roof. Slipped slates in one corner are a repair. Slipped slates everywhere are nails.

The condition of the timbers and underlay, seen from inside the loft. Look for water staining on rafters, wet insulation and torn felt.

The details. Chimney stacks, lead flashings, valleys and the junction with any rear addition or flat roof are where most leaks start.

How long you’re staying. Patching a tired roof before selling is reasonable. Patching it every winter for the next ten years isn’t.

A decent roofer should be able to say what they found and show photos of it. If water is coming in now, the first step is to stop the leak and protect the property. The bigger decision can be made once it’s dry.

The London roof

A lot of Georgian and early Victorian terraces have a valley roof hidden behind a front parapet, known as a butterfly or London roof. Two slopes drain into a central gutter that runs front to back. The parapet goes back to the London Building Act of 1707, one of a series of acts that followed the Great Fire. It banned timber eaves cornices, so the front wall was carried up as a brick parapet instead.

These roofs go wrong in the valley and the parapet gutter. Leaves, failed lead and a blocked outlet at the back mean water sits in the gutter and finds its way into the walls. Most of the time it’s a repair: new lead in the gutter, a properly sized outlet, cleaning. The covering on the slopes is often fine.

Budget

A repair costs less on the day. For a contained fault on a roof that’s otherwise sound, it’s the right money to spend.

The sums change when the same roof needs attention every winter. Every repair on a main roof of a terraced house usually needs access equipment, and on three storeys that’s a scaffold. Three or four years of that, plus ceilings and redecorating inside, can add up to a good part of a replacement.

A full re-roof costs more at the start but resets the covering, the battens and the membrane, fixes the insulation and usually sorts the lead and the chimney at the same time. The useful comparison is the cost per year over the next 10 to 20 years, not this week’s quote.

If the roof is young, sound and the problem is in one place, repair it properly. If it’s old, slipping all over or has been patched many times, plan the replacement before the next winter rather than after it. Either way the detailing decides how long it lasts: lead, valleys, ventilation, fixings and the joints between old and new.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to repair or replace a roof?

A repair is cheaper upfront and is right when the damage is in one place. On a roof that needs repairs every year or is close to the end of its life, replacement usually works out cheaper over time.

How do I know if my roof needs replacing?

Slates slipping all over the roof, daylight through the roof, sagging, torn or missing underlay, rotten timbers and repeated leaks after repairs. One of these may only need a repair, several together usually mean replacement.

How long does a roof repair last?

A repair that fixes the cause, such as new lead or replaced slates, can last as long as the rest of the roof. A patch with sealant over the symptom usually fails within a season or two.

Can I replace only part of my roof?

Yes, one slope or one section can be re-roofed if the rest is sound, which is common on rear additions. New slates or tiles may look different for a while, and if the rest of the roof is old, it may only delay the full job.

Should I repair a roof before selling the house?

If there’s an obvious leak or visible damage, usually yes. Buyers’ surveyors will pick it up and it becomes a negotiation point.

Who can check whether my roof needs repair or replacement?

An experienced roofing contractor who goes up on the roof and into the loft, and reports on the covering, timbers, flashings and drainage with photos.

Roof needs attention?

Talk it through with Force Builders Ltd — straight answers, no obligation. Over 25 years building across London.

Force Builders Ltd

Force Builders Ltd is a London building company (Companies House 07049787) delivering house extensions, loft conversions and full refurbishments across Greater London. See our projects or get in touch.

Ready to start your project?

Contact us
Call us today077 6525 5189
Call now Get a quote