A side return adds width to the back of the house. A rear extension adds depth. On a Victorian or Edwardian terrace that difference usually decides the job before cost does. If the kitchen is a long dark galley with a passage running beside it, the passage is the space to use. If the room is a decent shape and simply too small, the extra floor goes out into the garden.
What the side return is
Most London terraces from the second half of the 1800s have a two-storey back addition, which builders call the outrigger. It held the scullery and the kitchen downstairs and a small bedroom or bathroom above. Between the outrigger and the neighbour’s boundary there’s a strip of yard, usually 1.5 to 2.5 metres wide. That strip is the side return.
It’s there partly because of the Public Health Act 1875, which let councils make byelaws about open space around houses, street widths and ventilation. Terraces built under those rules are still called byelaw terraces, and a long back addition with a narrow yard beside it is typical of them.
Filling it in usually adds somewhere around 10 to 18 m². It doesn’t take any garden. What it does is turn an L-shaped ground floor into a rectangle, so a table and an island can sit side by side and daylight from a glazed roof gets into the middle of the plan.
What the rear extension is
A rear extension goes straight out from the back wall into the garden, across the full width or part of it. A typical one on a terrace adds 15 to 25 m². It’s a simpler build: open ground, room for a mini digger if there’s access, and walls that aren’t running along a boundary for their whole length.
The cost is garden. A 3 metre extension on a 10 metre London garden takes close to a third of it. In some streets that’s fine. In others the garden is the reason people bought the house.
Space versus shape
A rear extension makes the existing room longer. If that room was dark, it’s now a longer dark room with a bright end. A side return makes the room wider, and that changes how it’s used.
So the useful question isn’t how many square metres you get. It’s what’s wrong with the room now. If the problem is shape and light, depth won’t fix it. If the problem is that there isn’t enough floor, width usually won’t either.
Cost and why the side return costs more per metre
Rough London build costs, before kitchen units, appliances and VAT:
| Type | Typical size | Build cost |
|---|---|---|
| Side return | 10 – 18 m² | £60,000 – £95,000 |
| Rear extension | 15 – 25 m² | £70,000 – £110,000 |
The side return looks like poor value on paper. The reasons are on site. There’s almost never side access, so spoil goes out and materials come in through the hall, bag by bag. The rainwater and soil pipes from the back addition usually run down the side return, often with an inspection chamber in the middle of it, so drains get diverted or built over. The trench runs tight against the boundary for its full length and is dug by hand. And the new roof has to meet the old outrigger wall along a long joint that needs proper flashing and a cavity tray, or it’ll leak.
A rear extension has the same materials and fewer of those problems. You get more floor for the money.
Planning: two different sets of limits
Both often go through as permitted development under Class A of the General Permitted Development Order 2015. They fall under different lines of it.
A rear extension is limited to 3 metres beyond the original rear wall on a terrace or semi, 4 metres on a detached house, and 4 metres high. Outside conservation areas, the larger home extension route under prior approval allows 6 and 8 metres.
A side return counts as a side extension, because it goes beyond a side wall of the original house. That brings in a different limit:
“the enlarged part of the dwellinghouse would extend beyond a wall forming a side elevation of the original dwellinghouse, and would— (i) exceed 4 metres in height, (ii) have more than a single storey, or (iii) have a width greater than half the width of the original dwellinghouse”
GPDO 2015, Schedule 2, Part 1, Class A.1(j)
The side wall here is the side wall of the outrigger. Half the width of the house is rarely a problem for a 2 metre passage. The height is the one to watch. Within 2 metres of the boundary, the eaves can’t go above 3 metres either, and on a side return the whole thing is within 2 metres of the boundary. That’s why most side returns have a sloping glazed roof or a low flat roof with a parapet kept under 3 metres.
In conservation areas the side return loses permitted development altogether:
“In the case of a dwellinghouse on article 2(3) land, development is not permitted by Class A if— … (b) the enlarged part of the dwellinghouse would extend beyond a wall forming a side elevation of the original dwellinghouse”
GPDO 2015, Schedule 2, Part 1, Class A.2(b)
Article 2(3) land covers conservation areas, National Parks and a few other protected designations. In London it effectively means conservation areas, and boroughs like Islington, Camden, Hackney, Lambeth and Richmond have a large share of their terraced streets inside one. A rear extension in a conservation area can still be permitted development within the basic limits. A side return there needs a planning application. Check the council’s conservation area map first. It’s usually the first thing the planning and design stage looks at, because it decides whether you’re waiting eight weeks for a decision or not at all.
Building regulations apply to both either way. That’s a separate approval from planning.
The boundary wall in a side return
On a rear extension, the party wall work is usually at one or both ends. On a side return it runs the whole length of the job.
What’s on the boundary matters. If it’s a fence or nothing at all, and you’re building a new wall right up to the line, section 1 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 applies:
“If the building owner desires to build on the line of junction a wall placed wholly on his own land he shall, at least one month before he intends the building work to start, serve on any adjoining owner a notice which indicates his desire to build and describes the intended wall.”
Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 1(5)
If the boundary is an old brick garden wall sitting astride the line, that’s a party fence wall. Raising it, cutting into it or building off it is section 2 work, and the notice period is two months. The footings will also be close enough to the neighbour’s house that the excavation notice under section 6 usually comes into it too.
The Act itself is a London export. Its rules come from the London Building Acts, which governed party walls in the old LCC area for decades, and the 1996 Act extended them to the rest of England and Wales from July 1997.
Build time and living with it
A rear extension is usually ten to sixteen weeks on site. A side return is often ten to fourteen, despite being smaller, because hand-digging, drain work and moving everything through the house all take time.
The disruption is different. A rear extension opens the back of the house more or less in one go, and the kitchen is out for most of the job. With a side return the house stays usable for longer, but the hall becomes the route for every barrow, and the neighbour has trades working against their wall for weeks. Sequencing that properly is what the pre-construction work is for. The kitchen itself, layouts and what to decide early are covered in the guide to kitchen extensions in London.
When doing both makes sense
Some houses need both: the shape fixed and more floor. A wraparound does the side return and the rear extension as one L-shaped job. Scaffolding, drainage, roofing and the disruption are paid for once. It usually needs full planning, though. The details are in the guide to wraparound and double storey extensions.
Deciding
Stand in the room and work out what’s wrong with it. Dark and badly shaped with a passage outside points to a side return. A good shape but too small, with garden to spare, points to a rear extension. Both, with the budget, points to a wraparound.
The usual mistake is picking the bigger extension because the cost per square metre looks better, then finding the room still doesn’t work. Whether the room works is what you live with afterwards. More on the options across London is on the house extensions page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a side return cheaper than a rear extension?
Usually a bit cheaper in total but more expensive per square metre. The cost comes from access through the house, drain diversions and hand-digging along the boundary.
Which adds more value to a London house?
Neither reliably returns more than it cost. A side return that turns a galley kitchen into a usable family room often helps a sale more than extra depth on a room that already worked.
Do I need planning permission for a side return?
Often not, outside conservation areas. It has to be single storey, no wider than half the original house and no more than 4 metres high, with eaves under 3 metres near the boundary. In a conservation area a side extension needs planning.
Can I do a side return and a rear extension at different times?
Yes, but it costs noticeably more. Scaffolding, drainage, roof junctions and the disruption are all paid for twice, and the second job may not fit permitted development once the first is built.
How long does a side return extension take?
Typically ten to fourteen weeks on site, plus design and approvals before that. Tight access means it rarely goes faster than a larger rear extension.
Will a side return affect my neighbour?
Yes. You’ll be building on or near the boundary for the whole length of the job, so party wall notices apply: one month for a new wall on your side of the line, two months for work to an existing party wall.
Planning a project in London?
Talk it through with Force Builders Ltd — straight answers, no obligation. Over 25 years building across London.
Force Builders Ltd is a London building company (Companies House 07049787) delivering house extensions, loft conversions and full refurbishments across Greater London. See our projects or get in touch.
