Skip to content
Flat roof and pitched roof on London homes – comparison

Posts

Flat Roof vs Pitched Roof: Which One Is Better for Your Home?

“Which is better, flat or pitched?” We probably hear that once a week. And the honest answer, which nobody ever seems to enjoy, is that it depends on your house.

Sorry. But it really does. We’ve put both on all sorts of London properties over the years, and the times a roof went wrong it was almost never because someone picked the “wrong” type. It was because they picked it for the wrong reason, or because it was put on badly. So instead of a verdict, here’s how we’d think it through if it were our own extension, loft or roof replacement.

Flat roofs (which aren’t flat)

Funnily enough, a flat roof that’s actually flat is a bad flat roof. It needs a slight fall so the rain runs off. Not much, you’d barely notice it standing on it, but enough. Without it you get a puddle that hangs around for days after every shower, and sooner or later that puddle finds a seam. Half the horror stories people tell us about flat roofs come from old felt jobs done in the seventies and eighties with no real fall at all.

The ones we fit now are a different thing. EPDM rubber or GRP, laid over a warm roof (insulation on top of the deck, rather than squashed between the joists), will happily do 20 to 30 years. You’ll want to pull the leaves out of the outlet every autumn. That’s about it.

Where a flat roof really comes into its own is the back of a terraced house. Your neighbour’s kitchen window might be a metre from your new wall, and they won’t thank you for a big roof towering over it. A flat roof keeps everything low. It’s also the easy way to get a proper lantern or a long rooflight over the kitchen, and in those narrow Victorian houses where the middle of the ground floor never sees daylight, that one bit of glass changes how the whole house gets used. It’s the go-to for most London rear extensions, and plenty of modern home refurbishments are designed around that look.

The downside? They’re unforgiving. A flat roof is only as good as its fiddliest bits, the edges, the outlet, and especially the joint where the new roof meets the old wall of the house. Rush any of those and nothing happens for a year or so. Then a brown mark turns up on your freshly painted ceiling, right above the new kitchen island. Always there, for some reason.

Pitched roofs

A pitched roof doesn’t have to think very hard. Water lands on it, rolls down, ends up in the gutter. That simplicity is why it’s what most London houses already have, and why a decent slate roof can outlive the people who paid for it. Sixty years isn’t unusual.

On a period house it usually just looks right, too. Stick a pitched extension on the back of a 1930s semi in Ealing, match the tiles, and in five years no one will be able to tell which bit was added. If you’re in a conservation area or the back of the house is on show from the road, that might settle it before cost even comes up.

Here’s the bit that catches people out. A pitched roof on a single-storey extension needs height where it meets the house, and on lots of terraces there just isn’t any, because there’s a bedroom window sitting right where the roof wants to go. Add the permitted development limit (eaves no higher than 3 metres if you’re within 2 metres of the boundary) and sometimes it simply won’t fit. What you end up with is a lean-to so shallow the tiles can’t cope with it. Most tiles need somewhere between 15 and 25 degrees to keep water out, depending on which ones.

When it does fit, though, you get the one thing a flat roof can’t give you: a sloping ceiling inside. Leave the rafters on show or plaster it smooth, put in a couple of roof windows, and a fairly ordinary extension starts to feel enormous.

And then lofts, which are a pitched roof story by definition. In a loft conversion the existing roof shape decides nearly everything, from whether you go dormer or mansard or hip-to-gable to how much standing room you’ll end up with.

Cost

For a simple rear extension, a flat roof will nearly always be the cheaper option. Less timber, less labour, quicker to get watertight.

Pitched costs more. More timber, tiles or slate, lead where it meets the walls, longer on the scaffold. And on a tight London plot every bit of that has to come through the house or over the top of it. You’re talking a proper chunk on top of the roof budget, not a few hundred quid.

Mind you, a flat roof that’s done on the cheap and needs early repairs after three years, plus a new ceiling and redecorating underneath, isn’t cheap anymore. We’d rather quote a flat roof properly and lose the job than quote it cheap and get the phone call later.

Insulation and condensation

People assume one shape is warmer. It isn’t really about shape. It’s about what goes in the roof.

On a flat roof we’ll almost always build a warm roof, insulation over the deck and the waterproofing over that. The older cold roof way, insulation between the joists with an air gap above, gets condensation far too easily, and a kitchen extension with the kettle and the hob going all day is the worst place for it. Pitched roofs are more flexible. You can insulate the ceiling and leave the loft cold, or go along the rafters if you want to use the space.

Skimp on the insulation and your lovely new extension will be freezing in January and stuffy in July. Building Control will want to see it done right anyway.

Planning and building regulations

The roof can have more to do with planning than you’d expect. Height, bulk, what it’s made of, how much of it the neighbours have to look at. Lots of single-storey extensions go through under permitted development, but the height rules near a boundary are tight. One thing people often assume: a flat roof is not a free roof terrace. Terraces and balconies need full planning permission.

Building regulations are a separate box to tick, covering structure, insulation, drainage, ventilation and fire. Flat or pitched, they still apply. Get the roof decided before the drawings and the steels are finalised. Changing your mind once the walls are up is where budgets go to die.

Or a bit of both

More of our extensions than you’d think end up as a mix. Pitched where it can be seen, flat with a lantern where it can’t. Or a flat roof tucked behind a little parapet so the outline stays tidy from the garden. If you’ll be looking down on it from a bedroom window, a sedum roof is worth a thought, because a green roof is a lot nicer to look at over breakfast than grey rubber.

If we had to boil it down: modern back extension, lots of light, keep it low, go flat. Roof on show, house full of period character, fancy a vaulted ceiling and you’ve got the height for it, go pitched. And if you’re torn, ask us before the drawings are done, not after.

We do extensions, lofts, refurbs and roofing all over London, so we tend to look at the roof as part of the whole job. Send over your plans or a few photos of the back of the house and we’ll tell you what we’d do, even if the answer is “probably not what you were hoping”.

Planning a new roof?

Talk it through with Force Builders Ltd — straight answers, no obligation. Over 25 years building across London.

Force Builders Ltd

Force Builders Ltd is a London building company (Companies House 07049787) delivering house extensions, loft conversions and full refurbishments across Greater London. See our projects or get in touch.

Ready to start your project?

Contact us
Call us today077 6525 5189
Call now Get a quote